Losing Lena
City-Journal - In the Heart of Freedom, in Chains, by Myron Magnet
Elite hypocrisy, gangsta culture, and failure in black America
It’s a long (looong) essay (but a quick read), but of all of it this part stood out, because it’s something I was pondering on the other day (forget why):
A vicious circle now operates between the gangsta kids and the police. The kids dislike and fear the cops; the cops—looking for suspects whom victims have described as black, or seeing youths dressed as gangstas behaving as if they might be carrying weapons—stop law-abiding blacks, who then feel all the more victimized, angry, and resentful. And when frightened officers, black or white, mistakenly kill an innocent black man, like Amadou Diallo, such kids—and their mothers and neighbors, who write to City Journal often to say so—take it as proof that the cops are out to kill blacks on purpose. “I am scared for my son,” one mother wrote us recently. “The police always harassing the wrong people & jumping out of cars spot checking, . . . while the criminals sit around the neighborhood all day. . . . Was 50 shots necessary for Sean Bell? Or 45 shots for Diallo? . . . Come on, we all know none of these situations would ever happen to any white kids.” And you understand how she feels.
But one solution, if the mother knows who the real criminals are, is to “snitch.” Another, as a former juvenile-court chief prosecutor puts it, is: “If you don’t want to be treated like a thug, don’t dress like a thug. It’s an invitation to ‘probable cause.’ ” After all, urban black culture wasn’t always like this. Just look through old photos of Harlem and see young men and women dressed up like fashion plates out of Henry James or Thomas Mann, or like Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. Look at the black musical celebrities who took such care and made such an impression on people my age: Count Basie, with his elegant mustache, always in a tie and jacket; Duke Ellington, debonair in white tie and jauntily cocked top hat; gorgeous Lena Horne, radiant in her shimmering evening gown—all with the bearing of counts and dukes. What would they make of the gangstas?
sigh
July 23rd, 2007 at 3:22 pm
You remind me that I forgot to blog about the guy in the waiting room at a recent doctor’s visit. He didn’t dress particularly thug-like, and he spoke English with perfect diction and without a trace of slang. Yet he was unashamed of the conversation he was having on his cell phone about his eminent trip to jail because he wasn’t able to beat all of the 20 counts against him. Then he started advising his interlocutor about what to do about his armed robbery charges.
Me, I wouldn’t have that conversation in public.
July 23rd, 2007 at 4:36 pm
There was a guy in the waiting room during one of my own recent doctor’s visits who was dressed like a thug, spent most of the time sitting beneath a hood pulled low over his face so only he could see (maybe up to the ankles of) the rest of us, baggy pants sagged low, legs spread, sitting with his crotch facing the rest of us, including the two adorable children in the middle of the room playing fort with a magazine ottoman, hardly moving. Until he got bored, started playing bad tinny rap music loudly on his cell phone, gulped noisily at his Pepsi can, belched loudly, two or three times, to make sure it was all out, I guess, got up to stretch his legs by pacing menacingly along the reception counter, then sitting down again and announcing to no one in particular how bored he was.
I would have preferred the armed robber.
July 24th, 2007 at 2:59 am
… or a stylish cat burglar ala Cary Grant in “To Catch a Thief”.
July 24th, 2007 at 8:57 am
… or just Cary Grant.